DETERMINED IN

THE SUPREME COURT

OF THE

STATE OF CALIFORNIA,

AT THE

APRIL, JULY, AND OCTOBER TERMS, 1873.

CHARLES A. TUTTLE,

REPORTER.

Volume 46.

SAN FRANCISCO:
SUMNER WHITNEY & CO.,

613 CLAY STREET.

A. L. BANCROFT & CO.,

721 MARKET STREET.

1879.