Council and Hierarchy: The Political Thought of William Durant the YoungerCambridge University Press, 09.05.2002 - 416 Seiten In 1311, at the council of Vienne, William Durant the Younger (c. 1266-1330), the French bishop and count, demanded that general councils ought to meet every ten years in order to place effective limits on the papal plenitude of power because 'what touches all must be approved by all'. This is the first systematic interpretation of William Durant's remarkable project to transfer supreme legislative authority from the papacy to general councils. It suggests that the conciliar theory has a more ambivalent complexion than is sometimes recognized. It confirms, on the one hand, that constitutional ideas were deeply embedded in the tradition of the church, which enabled Durant to anticipate the council of Constance by more than a hundred years. On the other hand, Durant attributed an authority to ancient law that overrode his republican ideas, sapped their vitality, and launched him on a pursuit of the true meaning of the law that could end only in his transformation into an historian and a reluctant champion of monarchy. William Durant the Younger's ideas thus help us to understand both the origins of the conciliar theory and the transition from late medieval reform movements to early modern humanism and princely sovereignty. |
Im Buch
Ergebnisse 1-5 von 86
Seite i
... papacy to general councils . It suggests that the conciliar theory has a more ambivalent complexion than is sometimes recognized . It confirms , on the one hand , that constitutional ideas were deeply embedded in the tradition of the ...
... papacy to general councils . It suggests that the conciliar theory has a more ambivalent complexion than is sometimes recognized . It confirms , on the one hand , that constitutional ideas were deeply embedded in the tradition of the ...
Seite 1
... papacy as Cluny . The notion of reform in the middle ages has been thoroughly investigated ; Burdach , Reformation , Renaissance , Humanismus , Ladner , The Idea of Reform , and Panofsky , Renaissance and Renascences are three basic ...
... papacy as Cluny . The notion of reform in the middle ages has been thoroughly investigated ; Burdach , Reformation , Renaissance , Humanismus , Ladner , The Idea of Reform , and Panofsky , Renaissance and Renascences are three basic ...
Seite 2
... papacy would still be free to change existing laws by granting dispensations , Durant declared explicitly that the papacy was not to ' issue any dispensations , privileges , or exemptions contrary to the provident conciliar ...
... papacy would still be free to change existing laws by granting dispensations , Durant declared explicitly that the papacy was not to ' issue any dispensations , privileges , or exemptions contrary to the provident conciliar ...
Seite 3
... papacy had granted to the mendicant orders , which the prelates of France regarded as a direct violation of their rights and which provoked them into clear statements both of their understanding of the state of the church and of their ...
... papacy had granted to the mendicant orders , which the prelates of France regarded as a direct violation of their rights and which provoked them into clear statements both of their understanding of the state of the church and of their ...
Seite 4
... papacy and with the proviso that their decisions were invalid unless they received the approval of the pope . Requiring the pope to obtain the approval of a general council for all new legislation was a complete reversal ; substituting ...
... papacy and with the proviso that their decisions were invalid unless they received the approval of the pope . Requiring the pope to obtain the approval of a general council for all new legislation was a complete reversal ; substituting ...
Inhalt
THE BISHOPS OF MENDS | 31 |
The bishop and the nobility | 34 |
Aldebert de Tournel 115187 | 39 |
William de Peyre 118701222 | 43 |
Stephen of Brioude 122247 | 45 |
Odilo de Mercoeur 124774 | 49 |
THE STATE OF THE CHURCH | 55 |
The bishops between king and pope | 57 |
Reform of the members | 184 |
Reform of the head | 200 |
The rule of universal reason | 212 |
6 RES PUBLICA | 217 |
The commonwealth of Rome | 218 |
Truth and utility | 223 |
Money work and force | 230 |
The rule of the common good | 241 |
William Durant the elder 128596 | 64 |
THE TWILIGHT OF AUTONOMY | 73 |
Crisis | 80 |
Political manoeuvres | 83 |
The Pareage of Mende | 86 |
Private property and public power | 94 |
Durants ascendancy | 95 |
LIBERTY AND COMPROMISE | 101 |
THE ASSERTION OF JUSTICE | 113 |
THE THEORY OF REFORM | 115 |
Structure of the Tractatus Maior | 118 |
Style of the Tractatus Maior | 122 |
Reforms in head and members | 129 |
Reform by law | 132 |
Government bound by law | 135 |
Government bound by reason and precedent | 144 |
Reform by council | 156 |
Dispensation and exemptions | 168 |
MAGNUS ORDO DIFFERENTIE | 177 |
Concord and schism | 179 |
THE PERVERSION OF ORDER | 247 |
History and sovereignty | 256 |
Origins of conciliarism | 267 |
LIBERTY AND LAW | 277 |
THE INCIDENCE OF POWER | 285 |
THE SUBLIMATION OF REFORM | 287 |
Reception of the Tratatus Maior in Vienne | 290 |
Tractatus Minor | 294 |
THE ADVENT OF THE PRINCE | 305 |
The turning point | 307 |
The denouement | 311 |
CONCLUSION | 315 |
A note on texts and citations | 321 |
Bibliography | 326 |
Published sources | 327 |
Secondary literature | 332 |
Concordance | 367 |
376 | |
392 | |
Andere Ausgaben - Alle anzeigen
Council and Hierarchy: The Political Thought of William Durant the Younger Constantin Fasolt Eingeschränkte Leseprobe - 2002 |
Council and Hierarchy: The Political Thought of William Durant the Younger Constantin Fasolt Keine Leseprobe verfügbar - 1991 |
Häufige Begriffe und Wortgruppen
Aldebert aliis ancient laws authority bishop bishop of Mende Boniface VIII canon law canonists century chapter church Clement clergy clerics commonwealth conciliar movement conciliar proposal conciliar theory concilii council of Vienne Decretum diocese dispensations distinction Durant's ideas ecclesia ecclesiastical Ecclesiology enim eorum episcopal etiam Evêques-comtes exemptions France generalis Gévaudan golden bull Gratian Gratian's Gregory Guillaume Durand hierarchy Histoire iura iuris John XXII jurisdiction king Konzil von Vienne Languedoc limitanda potestate lord Marvejols medieval Mende mendicants Mittelalters monarchy Müller nobility obedience Odilo omnia order of difference Ordonnances papa papacy papal paréage Paris Peyre Philip Philip IV Philip the Fair Political Thought pope Porée principle Pseudo-Isidore quam quia quibus quod reason reform Roman Rome royal rulers secular secundum seneschal sicut sovereignty Strayer sunt super temporal Tierney Tournel Tractatus Maior treatise universal Videretur Viollet vols William William Durant Younger
Verweise auf dieses Buch
Rethinking The Foundations of Modern Political Thought Annabel Brett,James Tully Eingeschränkte Leseprobe - 2006 |