August, 1787, p. 380; 24th August, 1787, p. 471; 4th September, 1787, p. 507; 6th September, 1787, p. 516. Debates in the Convention of Virginia, 18th June, 1788, Elliot, vol. 3, pp. 488, 496. Debates in the Convention of North Carolina, 26th July, 1788, Elliot, vol. 4, p. 105. Debates in the Convention of Pennsylvania, 11th December, 1787, Elliot, vol. 2, p. 511. Debates in the Convention of North Carolina, 24th July, 1788, Elliot, vol. 4, p. 32; 25th July, 1788, Elliot, vol. 4, p. 43; 28th July, 1788, Elliot, vol. 4, p. 113. NOTE 89, PAGE 151. NOTE 100, PAGE 181. 595 See Debates above, p. 137, and references at note 82. NOTE 101, PAGE 182. See Debates above, p. 138, and references at note 83. NOTE 102, PAGE 182. See Debates below, 13th June, 1787, p. 190; 26th July, 1787, p. 376; 6th August, 1787, p. 381; 30th August, 1787, p. 498; 10th September, 1787, p. 530; 15th September, 1787, p. 551. Debates in the Convention of Massachusetts, 30th January, 1788, Elliot, vol. 2, p. 115; 1st February, 1788, Elliot, vol. 2, p. 138; 5th February, 1788, Elliot, vol. 2, p. 155. Debates in the Convention of Virginia, 4th June, 1788, Elliot, vol. 3, p. 25; 5th June, 1788, Elliot, vol. 3, p. 48; 6th June, 1788, Elliot, vol. 3, pp. 88, 94; 10th June, 1788, Elliot, vol. 3, p. 194; 25th June, 650. 1788, Elliot, vol. 3, pp. 630, 636, 647, Debates in the Convention of North Carolina, 29th July, 1788, Elliot, vol. 4, p. 176. NOTE 103, PAGE 183. See Debates below, 23d July, 1787, p. 352; 26th See Debates above, p. 141, and references at July, 1787, p. 376; 6th August, 1787, p. 381; 30th note 84. NOTE 90, PAGE 154. See Debates below, 6th June, 1787, p. 164; 13th June, 1787, p. 190; 21st July, 1787, p. 344; 6th August, 1787, p. 378; 15th August, 1787, p. 428. The Federalist, No. 51; No. 73. Debates in the Convention of Pennsylvania, 1st December, 1787, Elliot, vol. 2, p. 447; 4th December, 1787, Elliot, vol. 4, p. 429. August, 1787, p. 498. Debates in the Convention of Connecticut, 9th January, 1788, Elliot, vol. 2, p. 202. Debates in the Convention of New York, 7th July, 1788, Elliot, vol. 2, p. 409. Debates in the Convention of North Carolina, 30th July, 1788, Elliot, vol. 4, p. 196. Debates in Congress, 6th of May, 1789, Elliot, vol. 4, p. 342. NOTE 105, PAGE 184. See Debates below, 13th June, 1787, p. 189; 21st June, 1787, p. 224; 26th July, 1787, p. 375; 6th August, 1787, p. 377. Debates in the Convention of Massachusetts, 14th January, 1788, Elliot, vol. 2, p. 4; 15th January, 1788, Elliot, vol. 2, pp. 5 to 21. Debates in the Convention of New York, 21st June, 1788, Elliot, vol. 2, p. 241. Debates in the Convention of Pennsylvania, 4th December, 1787, Elliot, vol. 2, p. 464; 11th December, 1787, Elliot, vol. 2, p. 532. Debates in the Convention of Virginia, 4th June, 1788, Elliot, vol. 3, p. 14. Debates in the Convention of North Carolina, 24th July, 1788, Elliot, vol. 4, p. 26. The Federalist, No. 52; No. 53. NOTE 106, PAGE 185. See Debates below, 22d June, 1787, p. 226; 23d June, 1787, p. 230; 26th June, 1787, p. 245; 26th July, 1787, pp. 374, 375; 6th August, 1787, pp. 377, 378; 8th August, 1787, p. 388; 10th August, 1787, p. 402; 13th August, 1787, p. 411; 14th August, 1787, p. 420; 1st September, 1787, p. 503; 3d September, 1787, p. 504. Debates in the Convention of Massachusetts, 17th January, 1788, Elliot, vol. 2, p. 35; 21st January, 1788, Elliot, vol. 2, p. 52. Debates in the Convention of Virginia, 14th June, 1788, Elliot, vol. 3, p. 367; 27th June, 1788, Elliot, vol. 3, p. 661. Letter of Edmund Randolph, Elliot, vol. 1, p. 491. Address of Luther Martin to the Legislature of Maryland, 27th January, 1788, Elliot, vol. 1, p. 365. The Federalist, No. 52; No. 55; No. 56. See Debates below, 13th June, 1787, p. 190; 15th June, 1787, p. 192; 18th June, 1787, p. 205; 18th July, 1787, p. 331; 26th July, 1787, p. 376; 6th August, 1737, p. 379; 27th August, 1787, p. 481; 28th August, 1787, p. 483. Debates in the Convention of Massachusetts, 30th January, 1788, Elliot, vol. 2, p. 111. Debates in the Convention of Virginia, 18th June, 1788, Elliot, vol. 3, p. 517; 20th June, 1788, Elliot, vol. 3, p. 531; 21st June, 1788, Elliot, vol. 3, p. 563; 23d June, 1788, Elliot, vol. 3, p. 577. Debates in the Convention of North Carolina, 28th July, 1788, Elliot, vol. 4, p. 136; 29th July, 1788, Elliot, vol. 4, p. 153. Debates in the Convention of Pennsylvania, 7th December, 1787, Elliot, vol. 2, p. 486; 11th December, 1787, Elliot, vol. 2, p. 515. Address of Luther Martin to the Legislature of Maryland, 27th January, 1788, Elliot, vol. 1, p. 370. Objections of George Mason to the Federal Constitution, Elliot, vol. 1, p. 495. Report of James Madison to the Legislature of Virginia, 7th January, 1800, Elliot, vol. 4, pp. 548, 563. The Federalist, Nos. 80 to 83. Story's Commentaries on the Constitution, vol. 3, pp. 499 to 651. NOTE 109, PAGE 189. In the Journal of the Federal Convention, p. 121, the vote of Pennsylvania is given in the negative. The remarks of Mr. Butler, on this motion, as reported in Yates's Minutes, are somewhat different, Elliot, vol. 1, p. 409. See Debates below, 5th July, 1787, p. 273; 6th July, 1787, p. 282; 16th July, 1787, p. 316; 26th July, 1787, p. 375; 6th of August, 1787, p. 377; 8th August, 1787, p. 394; 9th August, 1787, pp. 395, 396; 11th August, 1787, p. 410; 13th August, 1787, p. 414; 14th August, 1787, p. 422; 15th August, 1787, p. 428; 5th September, 1787, pp. 510, 511; 8th September, 1787, p. 529. NOTE 113, PAGE 198. These speeches of Mr. Lansing, Mr. Patterson, ported in Yates's Minutes of this day's debate. Mr. Wilson, and Mr. Randolph, are very fully reSee Elliot, vol. 1, pp. 410 to 417. See also Mr. Martin's statement in regard to the to the Legislature of Maryland, 27th January, 1788, debate on Mr. Patterson's resolutions in his Address Elliot, vol. 1, p. 349. NOTE 114, PAGE 205. See Appendix, No. V., p. 584, for "Copy of a paper communicated to James Madison by Col. Hamilton, about the close of the Convention in Philadelphia, 1787, which, he said, delineated the Constitution which he would have wished to be proposed by the Convention." Yates's Minutes, 18th June, 1787, Elliot, vol. 1, p. 417. Debates in the Convention of New York, 20th June, 1788, Elliot, vol. 2, p. 230; 21st June, 1788, Elliot, vol. 2, pp. 251, 262; 24th June, 1788, Elliot, vol. 2, p. 300; 25th June, 1788, Elliot, vol. 2, p. 315; 27th June, 1788, Elliot, vol. 2, p. 347; 28th June, 1788, Elliot, vol. 2, pp. 356, 360. NOTE 118, PAGE 213. Yates's Minutes, Elliot, vol. 1, p. 425. Debates in the Convention of Virginia, 14th June, January, 1788, Elliot, vol. 2, p. 54. 1788, Elliot, vol. 3, p. 375. Objections of George Mason, one of the Delegates from Virginia, Elliot, vol. 1, p. 494. Address of Luther Martin to the Legislature of Maryland, 27th January, 1788, Elliot, vol. 1, 336. NOTE 110, PAGE 190. These resolutions will be found in the Journal of the Federal Convention, 19th June, 1787, p. 134. There are verbal differences in the first, fourth, seventh, eighth, ninth, tenth, eleventh, thirteenth, fifteenth, and nineteenth resolutions. NOTE 111, PAGE 193. Journal of Federal Convention, 15th June, 1787, p. 123. In the copy here given, the two following reso lutions, stated in the Journal to have been offered by Mr. Patterson with the rest, are entirely omitted. "Resolved, That the legislative, executive, and judiciary powers, within the several states, ought to be bound by cath to support the Articles of Union. "Resolved, That provision ought to be made for hearing and deciding upon all disputes arising between the United States and an individual state, respecting territory." NOTE 119, PAGE 214. NOTE 112, PAGE 197. p. 429. Stated in Yates's Minutes to Gen. Charles C. Pinckney, Elliot, vol. 1, p. 415. Debates in the Convention of Pennsylvania, 26th November, 1787, Elliot, vol. 2, p. 422; 1st December, 1787, Elliot, vol. 2, pp. 445, 446, 447 NOTE 125, PAGE 221. Debates in the Convention of Pennsylvania, 28th NOTE 126, PAGE 223. See Debates below, p. 250. Debates in the Convention 1788, Elliot, vol. 3, p. 131. NOTE 143, PAGE 245. See Debates above, p. 187, and references at note 107. NOTE 144, PAGE 247. See Debates above, 12th June, 1787, p. 187; 13th of Virginia, 7th June, June, 1787, p. 190; 26th July, 1787, p. 375. See also references at note 106. The Federalist, Nos. 45, 46. NOTE 127, PAGE 224. See Debates above, p. 137, and references at note 82. NOTE 145, PAGE 247. In the Journal of the Federal Convention this vote is thus given: Connecticut, Pennsylvania, Delaware, Maryland, Virginia, North Carolina, ay, 6; Massachusetts, New York, New Jersey, South Carolina, Georgia, no, 5. NOTE 146, PAGE 248. See Debates above, 12th June, 1787, p. 187; 13th The propositions of Dr. Franklin, given below, in the debates of the 30th June, 1787, p. 266, are stated in his works to have been offered on this day, the 26th June. Franklin's Works, (Sparks's edition,) vol 5, p. 142. NOTE 147, PAGE 249. This speech of Mr. Martin is reported more fully in Yates's Minutes, 27th and 28th June, 1787, Elliot, vol. 1, pp. 453 to 457. See Debates above, 11th June, 1787, p. 182; 19th June, 1787, p. 211; 25th June, 1787, p. 238; 28th June, 1787, p. 253; 29th June, 1787, p. 257; 5th July, 1787, p. 274. See Debates below, 14th July, 1787, p. 311; 16th July, 1787, p. 317; 9th August, 1787, p. 397. Address of Luther Martin to the Legislature of Maryland, 27th January, 1787, Elliot, vol. 1, p. 348. NOTE 163, PAGE 291. New York, no; in the Journal of the Federal Convention, 10th July, 1787, p. 166. NOTE 164, PAGE 292. New York, no; in the Journal of the Federal Convention, 10th July, 1787, p. 166. NOTE 165, PAGE 293. See Debates below, 16th July, 1787, p. 316; 20th July, 1787, p. 339; 26th July, 1787, p. 375; 6th August, 1787, p. 377; 20th August, 1787, p. 451; 21st August, 1787, p. 452. Debates in the Convention of Massachusetts, 17th January, 1788; Elliot, vol. 2, p. 36. Address of Luther Martin to the Legislature of Maryland, 27th January, 1788; Elliot, vol. 1, p. 357. Debates in the Convention of New York, 2d June, 1788; Elliot, vol. 2, p. 274. The Federalist, No. 55, p. 312. NOTE 166, PAGE 293. This resolution is somewhat different, as given in the Journal of the Federal Convention, 10th July, 1787, p. 167. NOTE 167, PAGE 295. This resolution is somewhat different, as given in the Journal of the Federal Convention, 11th July, 1787, p. 168. NOTE 168, PAGE 306. See Debates above, 11th June, 1787, p. 181; 13th June, 1787, p. 190; 5th July, 1787, p. 273; 9th July, 1787, p. 288; 10th July, 1787, p. 293; 11th July, 1787, p. 295. See Debates below, 13th July, 1787, p. 307; 16th July, 1787, p. 316; 26th July, 1787, p. 375; 6th August, 1787, p. 379; 8th August, 1787, p. 391; 21st August, 1787, p. 453; 17th September, 1787, p. 555. Debates in the Convention of Massachusetts, 17th January, 1788, Elliot, vol. 2, p. 32; 18th January, 1788, Elliot, vol. 2, p. 40. Debates in the Convention of New York, 20th June, 1788, Elliot, vol. 2, pp. 226, 236; 21st June, 1788, Elliot, vol. 2, pp. 242, 252; 23d June, 1788, Elliot, vol. 2, p. 270. Debates in the Convention of Virginia, 4th June, 1788, Elliot, vol. 3, pp. 11, 30; 6th June, 1788, Elliot, vol. 3, p. 99; 7th June, 1788, Elliot, vol. 3, pp. 110, 124; 11th June, 1788, Elliot, vol. 3, p. 247; 12th June, 1788, Elliot, vol. 3, p. 320. Public Journals of Congress, 17th February, 1783, vol. 4, p. 162: 18th April, 1783, vol. 4, p. 190; 27th September, 1785, vol. 4, p. 587; 5th April, 1792, vol. 1, p. 563. Address of Luther Martin to the Legislature of Maryland, 27th January, 1787, Elliot, vol. 1, pp. 348, 363. Objections of George Mason to the Federal Constitution, Elliot, vol. 1, p. 494. Letter of Messrs. Yates and Lansing to the Legislature of New York, Elliot, vol. 1, p. 481. The Federalist, No. 36; No. 54; No. 55; and No. 58. Address of the Minority of the Convention of Pennsylvania to their Constituents, American Museum, vol. 2, pp. 547, 551. Letter of Richard Henry Lee, 16th October, 1787, Elliot, vol. 1, p. 503. Debates in Congress, 14th August, 1789, Gales and Seaton, (First Series,) vol. 1, p. 749; 21st August, 1789, vol. 1, p. 802. Jefferson's Works, vol. 4, p. 466. Story's Commentaries on the Constitution, vol. 2, p. 147. NOTE 169, PAGE 310. There are some verbal variations between the resolution, as given here, and that in the Journal of the Convention, p. 177. NOTE 170, PAGE 317. See Debates above, pp. 287, 306, and references at notes 162 and 168. NOTE 171, PAGE 317. See Debates above, 29th May, 1787, p. 127; 31st May, 1789, p. 139: 13th June, 1787. p. 190. See Debates below, 17th July, 1787, p. 319; 6th August, 1787, p. 378. NOTE 172, PAGE 320. Debates in the Convention of Virginia, 15th June, See Debates above, p. 174, and references at 1788, Elliot, vol. 3, p. 452; 17th June, 1788, Elliot, note 98. vol. 3, p. 481. Debates in the Convention of North Carolina, 26th July, 1788, Elliot, vol. 4, p. 100. Debates in the Convention of South Carolina, 16th January, 1788, Elliot, vol. 4, pp. 271, 276, 286, 295. Amendments to the Constitution proposed by the states. Supplement to the Journal of the Federa. Convention, p. 462. Debates in Congress, 13th May, 1789, Gales and Seaton, (First Series,) vol. 1, p. 352. Objections of George Mason to the Federal Con stitution, Elliot, vol. I, p. 496. The Federalist, No. 7, p. 36; No. 26; No. 42, No. 44, p. 252. NOTE 188, PAGE 370. Journal of the Federal Convention, 26th July, 1787, p. 204. There are some slight verbal differ ences. NOTE 189, PAGE 374. See Debates below, p. 376. NOTE 190, PAGE 376. Journal of the Federal Convention, 26th July, 1787, p. 207. The dates when each resolution was finally passed are there given. NOTE 191, PAGE 381. Journal of the Federal Convention, 6th August, 1787, p. 215. There are a few verbal differences. The original draught, from which each is taken, was printed, and is among the papers relating to the Convention, which were deposited by Gen. Washington in the Department of State, on the 19th March, 1796. NOTE 192, PAGE 382. The proceedings on this motion are more fully stated in the Journal of the Federal Convention, 7th August, 1787, p. 230. NOTE 193, PAGE 385. The Federalist, No. 52. NOTE 194, PAGE 389. See Debates above, 31st May, 1787, p. 135; 21st June, 1787, p. 223. Debates in the Convention of Virginia, 4th June, 1788, Elliot, vol. 3, p. 7. The Federalist, No. 52. NOTE 195, PAGE 391. See Debates above, p. 186, and references at note 106. NOTE 196, PAGE 394. See Debates above, p. 306, and references at note 168. NOTE 197, PAGE 395. See Debates above, p. 189, and references at note 109. NOTE 198, PAGE 401. Maryland, no; in the Journal of the Federal Con- June, 1787, p. 241. vention, 23d July, 1787, p. 198. NOTE 187, PAGE 357. See Debates below, 6th August, 1787, p. 379; 21st August, 1787, p. 453; 22d August, 1787, p. 457; 24th August, 1787, p. 470; 25th August, 1787, p. 477; 28th August, 1787, p. 486; 31st August, 1787, p. 502; 14th September, 1787, p. 546. Debates in the Convention of Pennsylvania, 3d December, 1787, Elliot, vol. 2, p. 451. Debates in the Convention of New Hampshire, Elliot, vol. 2, p. 203. Debates in the Convention of Massachusetts, 18th January, 1788, Elliot, vol. 2, p. 40; 25th January, 1788, Elliot, vol. 2, p. 106. See Debates above, 12th June, 1787, p. 187; 25th See Debates below, 13th August, 1787, p. 414. The Federalist, No. 62. NOTE 199, PAGE 402. See Debates above, 6th August, 1787, p. 377. Debates in the Convention of Massachusetts, 16th January, 1788, Elliot, vol. 2, p. 21; 17th January, 1787, Elliot, vol. 2, p. 29; 21st January, 1787, Elliot, vol. 2, p. 48. Debates in the Convention of Virginia, 4th June 1788, Elliot, vol. 3, p. 9; 5th June, 1788, Elliot, vol. 3, p. 60, 9th June, 1788, Elliot, vol. 3, p. 175; 14th June, 1788, Elliot, vol. 3, p. 366. Debates in the Convention of North Carolina, 25th July, 1788, Elliot, vol. 4, p. 50. |